Responsive Management - Boating

Boating

Recreational boating participation has been growing with the United States population. According to Responsive Management research, nearly a third of Americans 18 years old and older go boating each year. The increase in the number of recreational boaters, as well as increases in boat registration and the amount of time spent on the water, have led to increased demands for and use of public and private boating access, boating facilities, and boating supplies.

The majority of recreational boating in the United States is done in open motorboats under 26 feet in length. Furthermore, boats under 16 feet long are the most commonly used watercraft in recreational boating. Jet ski and other personal watercraft ownership have increased over the last decade, but still represent a minority of recreational boats used. Most recreational boating takes place on freshwater lakes or impoundments.

Inconsistent registration requirements confound the accurate collection of boating statistics. Standard, codified boating registration and accident reportage would increase the accuracy of analyses of boating participation, boat ownership and registration, and accident rates.
Income is correlated to boating recreation and boat ownership, contributing to the factors indicating that boat ownership is associated with middle-class sociodemographic characteristics. There is also a correlation between education and participation in recreational boating. Persons with graduate, professional, or undergraduate degrees are slightly more likely to participate in recreational boating. Ethnic minorities are under-represented in boating and boat ownership relative to the general population of the United States.

Although lack of access has been cited as a deterrent to recreational boating, Responsive Management research indicates that whether lack of access to the water is a constraint to boating participation varies state by state. In some states, lack of access to the water does indeed appear to be a constraint and boaters cite the need for more and improved access sites, such as boat launch ramps. However, in other states, access is not a reason for dissatisfaction with boating, decreased boating activity, or not going boating more often.

Recreational boating satisfaction is not derived from the physical activities of boating itself. Rather, satisfaction from recreational boating, as in other types of outdoor recreation, tends to be about naturalistic experiences, rest and relaxation, and social issues in connection with friends and family. The fact that naturalistic experiences, being with friends and family, relaxation, and other less tangible reasons are of primary importance, and proximal factors such as costs, challenge, and physical characteristics of boats and/or boat performance are of less importance needs to be carefully considered in the development of management and marketing plans.

In response to the large number of boating injuries and fatalities, Congress passed the Federal Boat Safety Act of 1971 and later created the Aquatic Resources (Wallop-Breaux) Trust Fund in 1984. Both of these actions paid dividends, with a decline in the rate of boating injuries and fatalities.

While typically a majority of boaters do not participate in boating safety courses, they do participate in basic first aid, water safety, and/or rescue courses at a higher rate than that of the general population. Recreational boaters favor mandatory boating safety classes, but few feel they personally need safety training. Recreational boaters are more likely to favor mandatory boating safety requirements for new boat operators, especially personal watercraft operators.

Responsive Management’s boating research studies have examined boating participation and related characteristics (locations of boating, numbers and types of boats owned and registered, etc.); ratings of state boating programs, services, and facilities; opinions on boating access; activities while boating and motivations for boating; boating law enforcement; environmental issues connected to boating; constraints to boating; factors associated with boating accidents and fatalities; and more.

Recent examples of Responsive Management’s research on boating include the following:

  • Minimizing Marine Debris by Preventing Conflicts Between Recreational Boating and Commercial Fishing Groups: This study examined recreational boaters’ and commercial fishermen’s knowledge of ghostfishing and their opinions on factors that contribute to recreational boaters’ collisions and entanglements with fixed commercial fishing gear, as well as their experiences with and opinions on conflicts between recreational boaters and commercial fishermen in general. Qualitative data collection for this project entailed focus groups with recreational boaters and focus groups and personal telephone interviews with commercial fishermen.
  • Boat Owners’ Opinions on Factors Influencing the State in Which to Register Their Boat: This study was conducted to determine the extent to which various factors influence boat owners to register their vessel in a particular state. A key objective of this project was to explore whether a cap on the Maryland vessel excise tax that occurred in 2013 encouraged boaters to register a vessel in Maryland specifically. The study entailed a scientific multi-modal survey of owners of boats valued at $100,000 or more registered in Maryland or in various other states.
  • Enhancing Fishing Access Through a National Assessment of Recreational Boating Access: This study focuses on the intersection between boating and fishing activities. Recreational boating and fishing activities are intertwined and, consequently, as the number of participants in one activity falls, the other falls as well: conversely, as participation rises in one, it also rises in the other. This study was designed to determine whether a lack of boating access has contributed to decreases in participation and to create assessment tools for boating access that states and regions can replicate to measure their boating access programs and needs. Overall, the study included a review of previously published research; a series of focus groups with boaters; a focus group with boating industry representatives; a nationwide survey of boaters, including anglers who fish from a boat; and a national survey of boating industry representatives and boating agency professionals
  • “Wear It California!” Life Jacket Campaign Assessment: This study was conducted for the California Department of Boating and Waterways, the National Safe Boating Council, BoatU.S., and the U.S. Coast Guard to determine the effect of an intensive marketing effort to increase life jacket usage. This study entailed a survey of boaters who participated in the “Wear It California!” campaign by filling out a pledge card distributed by Wear It California staff and, more specifically, those program participants who had boated in the 12 months prior to the survey.
  • Georgia Boaters’ Attitudes and Opinions Regarding Boating in Georgia: This study was conducted for the Georgia Department of Natural Resources, Wildlife Resources Division, to determine Georgia registered boaters’ attitudes and opinions on a variety of boating and law enforcement issues. The study entailed a telephone survey of people who have a registered boat (or boats) in Georgia.
  • South Carolina Charter Vessel License Holders Survey: This study was conducted for the South Carolina Department of Natural Resources (SCDNR) to determine water access and other characteristics of for-hire trips conducted on South Carolina licensed charter vessels. The data was collected primarily to supplement and update the charter vessel logbook data collected periodically by the SCDNR. The study entailed a telephone survey of South Carolina charter vessel license holders, owners, and operators and an extensive electronic database update for each licensed charter vessel.
  • Boaters’ Preferences for and Opinions on Web-Based Boating Safety Courses: This study was conducted to assess boaters’ preferences for and opinions on boating safety courses offered by two major providers of online instruction for boaters. The study entailed a focus group of new and experienced boaters as well as a Web-based survey of boaters, all of whom had completed the preselected course material. Both the focus group and survey were constructed as non-preferential assessments of the two online courses.
  • Washington State Boater Needs Assessment: Authorized by the Washington State Legislature, this study was conducted for the Washington State Recreation and Conservation Office to determine the needs of Washington boaters and to help determine priorities for allocating resources. Utilizing focus groups of boating services providers, a telephone survey of boating services providers, a telephone survey of the general public in Washington, and a telephone survey of registered boaters in Washington, the assessment identified major needs of and issues facing recreational boating and provided implications and recommendations for meeting boater needs in Washington.
  • Washington State Boaters Survey Regarding Safety, Education, and Law Enforcement: As part of the effort to help the state carry out its responsibilities regarding boating programs, this study was conducted for the Washington State Parks and Recreation Commission to obtain Washington boaters’ attitudes toward, knowledge of, and behaviors primarily related to safety, education, and law enforcement, but also including data on boat ownership, registration, and documentation; importance of and satisfaction with boating in Washington; boating locations; boating-related efforts of the Commission; opinions on and knowledge of boating regulations; boating experiences and behaviors; and importance of various desired services.
  • Delaware Boater Survey: Boaters’ participation in boating, their knowledge of boating regulations, and their opinions about boating in Delaware were measured in a telephone survey of registered boaters in Delaware, including those who registered a boat in Delaware, even though their primary residence is out-of-state.
  • Indiana Boater Survey: This study entailed telephone surveys and focus groups of Indiana registered boaters and Indiana’s general population to determine their participation in, behaviors regarding, opinions on, and attitudes toward boating access, boating safety, and the boating programs and activities of the Indiana Department of Natural Resources. Boating expenditures were also measured.
  • Lake Tahoe Boater Survey: This study was conducted for the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency (TRPA) to determine the types and characteristics of boats and boat engines that Lake Tahoe boaters use, their avidity for boating, their opinions on boating at Lake Tahoe and boating regulations, and their opinions on and awareness of the TRPA, as well as their opinions and actions affecting Lake Tahoe’s environment. The study entailed personal intercepts and a telephone survey of Lake Tahoe boaters who had boated on Lake Tahoe in the previous year using a motorized watercraft.
  • Analysis of Factors Associated with Canoe and Kayak Fatalities: Conducted for the American Canoe Association, this study examined factors associated with canoe and kayak fatalities, based on 10 years of data in the U.S. Coast Guard’s Boating Accident Reporting Database (referred to as BARD data). Using regression analyses on BARD data, the research found the factors most associated with canoe and kayak fatalities, and those factors least associated with fatalities.
  • Media and Messages Encouraging the Use of Personal Flotation Devices: This study was conducted for the Boat U.S. Foundation to determine the effectiveness of various media and messages encouraging the use of personal flotation devices. The study entailed a telephone survey of and focus groups with boaters in four states: Washington, Georgia, New Jersey, and Indiana.
  • Arizona Boaters’ Opinions of Boating and Boating Safety Issues on Arizona’s Public Waters: The Arizona Game and Fish Department commissioned this telephone survey of registered boaters to assess their opinions on the safety of Arizona’s public waters, the testing and licensing of watercraft operators, their awareness of and participation in boating safety classes, and their attitudes toward numerous other boating safety issues.
  • Anglers’ and Boaters’ Attitudes Toward Various Messages that Communicate the Benefits of Fishing and Boating: For this project, Responsive Management conducted focus groups of lapsed anglers and lapsed boaters to identify core messages that best communicate the benefits of recreational boating, recreational fishing, and aquatic stewardship.
  • A Review of Boating Safety Education Programs Nationwide: A three-phase study was conducted for the National Association of State Boating Law Administrators under a grant from the U.S. Coast Guard to review boating safety education programs and to provide a needs assessment of boating safety education. Phase I of the study consisted of multi-modal surveys of State Boating Law Administrators and Education Coordinators to determine boating safety professionals’ attitudes toward boating safety programs and their professional recommendations for improving boating safety programs. Phase II consisted of a nationwide telephone survey of owners of registered boats to determine their opinions on and participation in boating safety education, as well as their perceptions and opinions on boating safety in general. Phase III is a synthesis of the Phase I and II reports, as well as data from a series of focus groups of owners of registered boats conducted after the Phase II nationwide telephone survey.
  • Factors Related to Boating Participation in the United States—A Review of the Literature: This report represents the most salient issues related to recreational boating in the United States. These issues and the information presented within the report are the result of an extensive review of current boating literature.
  • Licensed Motorboat Operators’ and Registered Personal Watercraft Users’ Opinions on and Attitudes Toward Motorized Boating in Wyoming: This study was conducted to assess licensed boat operators’ and registered personal watercraft users’ opinions on and attitudes toward motorized boating in Wyoming.
  • Kansas Residents’ Participation in, Opinions on, and Attitudes Toward Boating in Kansas: This study was conducted to assess Kansas residents’ participation in, opinions on, and attitudes toward boating in Kansas. This report specifically pertains to questions asked of persons who indicated they had power boated, sailboated, or fished from a boat during the 12 months prior to the survey.